Once Red-Hot Seller Markets Now Lead the U.S. in Canceled Home Sales
Home-purchase contract cancellations are climbing in areas that were once hot seller markets, according to a recent Redfin report. Cities like Atlanta, Fort Worth, and Jacksonville, Florida, are experiencing the highest share of deals falling through, signaling a shift toward buyer-friendly conditions.
Nationwide, the portion of buyers backing out of agreements is lower but stable. In May 2026, 13.6% of home-sale agreements were canceled, unchanged from April on a seasonally adjusted basis, and consistent with the last four months. Over the past two years, U.S. contract cancellations have hovered between 13.4% and 14%.
Why Deals Are Falling Through
Several factors contribute to contract cancellations in 2026:
- Affordability pressures due to higher mortgage rates
- Greater seller inventory, giving buyers more options
- Economic uncertainty, including inflation risk and job instability
- Geopolitical concerns, such as ongoing effects from international conflicts
Redfin notes that weekly mortgage rates have been above 6% since late 2022, impacting buyer purchasing power.
Metro Areas With the Highest Cancellations
| Metro | Cancellation Rate May 2026 | Buyer-to-Seller Ratio |
|---|---|---|
| Atlanta, GA | 18.8% | 1 buyer : 1.7 sellers |
| Fort Worth, TX | 18.1% | 1 buyer : 1.61 sellers |
| Jacksonville, FL | 17.9% | 1 buyer : 1.74 sellers |
| San Antonio, TX | 17.8% | 1 buyer : 2+ sellers |
| Orlando, FL | 17.7% | 1 buyer : 1.5+ sellers |
High cancellation rates reflect a surplus of sellers compared with buyers, giving purchasers the flexibility to back out if a preferred property becomes available.
Texas and Florida dominate this list, with multiple metros in each state appearing among the top 10 for cancellations.
Realistic Expectations Reduce Cancellations
Cancellations have declined from 2023 peaks as both buyers and sellers enter transactions with more realistic expectations:
- Sellers are adjusting asking prices to attract buyers.
- Negotiation is more common to keep deals on track.
- Buyers have adapted to higher housing costs and are more selective.
For example, a Redfin agent in Dallas described pricing strategies where sellers listed slightly below market expectations to ensure contracts closed successfully.
Markets With Low Cancellation Rates
Conversely, some metros have very low cancellation rates. San Francisco leads with only 3.9% of contracts falling through, largely due to strong demand tied to the AI and tech boom. Other low-cancellation areas include:
| Metro | Cancellation Rate May 2026 |
| Nassau County, NY | 3.9% |
| New York City, NY | 6.7% |
| San Jose, CA | 7.1% |
| Montgomery County, PA | 7.3% |
Low cancellation rates are associated with markets where high demand, strong employment growth, and limited inventory sustain buyer commitment.
Month-over-Month Shifts
Some metros saw an increase in cancellations in May 2026 compared to April:
- Portland, OR: 16.3% (up from 14.3%)
- Oakland, CA: 10.2% (up from 8.2%)
- Houston, TX: 16.9% (up from 15.0%)
- Sacramento, CA: 15.1% (up from 13.2%)
- Pittsburgh, PA: 15.1% (up from 13.9%)
Meanwhile, decreases were observed in:
- Columbus, OH: 15.1% (down from 17.2%)
- Cleveland, OH: 15.1% (down from 16.5%)
- Miami, FL and West Palm Beach, FL: slight decreases
- San Antonio, TX: slight decrease
Market Implications
The data highlights how market conditions have shifted since the pandemic:
- Buyer advantage: More sellers than buyers in key markets allow buyers to walk away and find alternatives.
- Seller pricing: Realistic listing prices help reduce cancellations.
- Regional variation: Southern metros and parts of Texas and Florida are more prone to canceled contracts, while tech-driven markets like San Francisco show higher deal stability.
As U.S. homebuyers adjust to higher mortgage rates, elevated inventory, and economic uncertainty, cancellation rates are serving as a key indicator of market dynamics in 2026. For direct financing consultations or mortgage options for you visit 👉 Nadlan Capital Group.
Responses